My Girlfriend Planned a Beach Proposal, but I Found Her Kissing Her “First Love” Instead

Chapter 2

4,849 words

“What? Can you stop being so unreasonable?”

Summer’s eyes widened as she stared at me, utterly stunned.

She clearly hadn’t expected someone who had always loved her unconditionally to suddenly suggest a breakup.

But my tone was calm. “I’m not being unreasonable. I’m serious.”

“You kissed Chase. What’s the point of continuing this relationship?”

Summer froze at my words, her expression faltering for just a moment before a flicker of guilt crossed her face.

“You… you saw that? When did you—”

Before she could finish, I cut her off with a bitter laugh.

“Right when you and Chase were so caught up in your kiss. You two really make a perfect match.”

Summer paused, then shot me a cold glare, her tone sharpening with anger.

“And whose fault is that? If you hadn’t been late, Chase wouldn’t have had to kiss me to diffuse the situation!”

“We agreed to meet at ten, but you didn’t show up until eleven. Do you know how humiliated I felt, standing there while everyone was ridiculing me?”

“And if you had arrived, why didn’t you come find me? Were you just standing there watching, hoping to see me embarrassed?”

I was speechless for a moment.

She was the one who had done something wrong, yet somehow she managed to twist it around and make it my fault.

Besides, I clearly remember sending her a message when I went to rent the suit and buy the flowers. Seems like she hadn’t even bothered to check.

Chase calls her once, and she’ll drop everything—even a meeting—to answer. But when I sent her over a dozen messages, she ignored them all without a second thought.

This was the difference between love and indifference, and I was finally starting to understand it.

“Summer, I sent you a mess—”

Before I could finish, the sound of a knock on the door interrupted me.

It was Chase.

The next second, he entered the apartment after punching in the code, as if it were his own home.

Judging by how natural and practiced he looked, it was clear this wasn’t his first time here.

This was my home. Mine and Summer’s. Yet she had given him the door code behind my back.

I turned to look at her, but she avoided my gaze, shifting uncomfortably.

Chase walked over to her, casually standing by her side, and said with a grin, “Summer, you left in such a rush earlier that I just realized I still had the engagement ring on me!”

“Good thing I noticed and came over to return it right away!”

As he spoke, he shot me a smug, taunting look, deliberately holding up the ring for me to see, his intention to provoke clear as day.

It was only then that I noticed the matching couples’ rings on their hands.

I lowered my gaze, my heart growing colder by the second.

Wasn’t he just “helping” her out of an awkward situation? Then why were they wearing matching rings?

Neither Summer nor I spoke, and the room was thick with tension.

Chase took advantage of the silence, pretending to lighten the mood while slyly fanning the flames.

“Are you two fighting? Ryan, don’t misunderstand. I only wore the engagement ring because I had no choice.”

“Back at the beach, I only kissed her because you didn’t show up on time. We thought you weren’t coming.”

“The moment was perfect, the crowd was cheering, and I didn’t want Summer to feel awkward. That’s all.”

“But really, nothing happened between us. We’re completely innocent. Don’t let me come between you two!”

Chase then turned to me with a fake smile. “I’ll take the ring off and return it to you right away.”

He started fiddling with the ring, but it was obvious he wasn’t trying very hard.

In fact, he made a big show of pretending it was stuck, rubbing his finger until it turned red. Then he looked at Summer with mock helplessness.

“Summer, it’s stuck! What should I do?”

Playing along, he forced a pitiful expression, as if he had tried his best.

Summer, of course, fell for it. She grabbed his hand, her voice soft and full of concern.

“If it’s stuck, don’t force it. It’s just a ring—don’t hurt yourself over it.”

Chase continued his act, still “struggling” to remove the ring as he glanced at me out of the corner of his eye.

“But this is the engagement ring you bought for Ryan…”

Summer, clearly irritated, glanced at me with annoyance, as if still upset about our argument.

“Then I’ll just buy him another one. It’s not a big deal. He’s not that petty.”

Hearing her dismiss me so easily, Chase’s smugness grew, and he shot me a triumphant look.

I, however, felt nothing but cold detachment.

This was how it always was.

Whenever it came down to choosing between me and Chase, she always chose Chase.

This wasn’t about a ring. It was about everything that had been broken between us.

Rings can be replaced. But a broken relationship? That can’t be fixed.

I smiled faintly, walked over, and placed their hands together.

“There’s no need to take it off. You two are perfect for each other. I wish you both the best.”

Get the NovelMaster app → search code 533910Download NovelMaster